Above each upside
Actions or experiments
When a warning shows up, what will we do to gain or keep the upside of the other pole?
- What
- Who
- By when
- How we will measure it
Strategy tool
A team maps a tension it cannot solve, two things it needs that keep pulling on each other, and learns to manage it on purpose.
Polarity Mapping is a way for a team to work with a tension between two things it needs, such as stability and innovation.
The team maps the upside and the downside of each pole, then agrees on the early warnings and the actions that keep it moving between them.
FUSE facilitators use it after a team has set its priorities, to show which parts of those priorities are polarities to manage.
It has an end point.
It is ongoing, and keeps coming back as conditions change.
It can be solved: analyze, decide, done.
It can only be managed over time.
The alternatives stand alone. Choosing one is enough.
The poles need each other. Focusing on one alone eventually backfires.
Before the map
Four yes answers mean it is a polarity to manage. A no usually means a problem to solve or a decision to make. It is still important, and it belongs outside this map.
Each pole gets a neutral name, usually one word. We say and every time, because both poles are necessary for a healthy organization.
When a pole sounds negative or like a department, we ask what value sits underneath. IT and Dev became Stability and Innovation.
At the wall
The whole group builds one map together first, and experiences the pattern before anyone names it.
The downside of the first pole. One idea per sticky note, until the group runs out.
What does it give us when it is working well?
What goes wrong when we over-focus on it and neglect the first pole?
What benefits does it bring?
The facilitator asks one question: what do you notice?
Then we name what the group has built: a pair of interdependent opposites. Over time the team needs both, and in any given moment, more of one means less of the other.
The dynamics
A polarity keeps moving, like an infinity loop. Lean into one pole long enough and the team dips into its downside. The way out is a shift toward the other pole.
“We’ll just focus on innovation.”
It works for a while. Then the team sinks deeper into that pole’s downside than it would have, and stays there until someone notices.
A new leader arrives or production crashes, and there is a sudden, violent swing to the other pole. Then back again. Jerky, and costly.
“I’ll get both upsides at once.”
Impossible by definition, like inhaling and exhaling together. The poles merge and the team ends up in both downsides.
The team notices the dip early and shifts, so the dips stay shallow and most of its time is spent in the upsides of both poles.
Managing a polarity well is like walking a tightrope: small corrections, made early. It takes courage to shift toward the other pole when preference is pulling the team to stay.
What makes the map usable
Above each upside
When a warning shows up, what will we do to gain or keep the upside of the other pole?
Below each downside
Things we can count, see or hear that tell us we are starting to slip into a downside, before we are deep in it.
Morale dropsToo vague to notice. We ask what the team could count.
In the room
Minutes from the start. We adapt the timing and the room to the group, and keep the order of the moves.
0 to 5
Whole group
Some tensions under a priority can be solved. Others can only be managed.
5 to 12
Breakouts
Each group takes a top priority and names the polarities inside it.
12 to 16
Whole group
Groups share their pole names. One becomes the live map.
16 to 30
At the wall
Four quadrants in order, then the step back.
30 to 37
Facilitator
The loop, the three myths, and what well managed looks like.
37 to 52
Breakouts
Each group maps its own polarity, with warnings and actions.
52 to 60
Whole group
One insight per group, and a date for the first review.
Nine leaders at a two-day strategic planning session mapped the tensions inside their top priorities, in three breakout groups.
60 to 75 minutes for a leadership team, in one sitting.
We build fewer maps and build them fully. One complete map, with its early warnings and actions, is worth more than two half-finished ones.
The goal is to keep moving between the poles on purpose: spend most of the time in both upsides, and keep the dips shallow by noticing early and shifting sooner.
The team agrees when it will review them together, who puts each map on the agenda, and the date of the first review. We photograph every map and keep them visible.
Polarity maps were introduced by Dr. Barry Johnson in his book Polarity Management: Identifying and Managing Unsolvable Problems. The comparison of problems and polarities is adapted from VeDA’s Polarities Wisdom materials.
Tell us about your team and what the session needs to achieve. We’ll design the day with you.
Book a discovery call